Search the forum,

Discuss Williams & Co 2017 boiler survey results in the Plumbing Jobs | The Job-board area at PlumbersForums.net

Status
Not open for further replies.
R

Ray Stafford

Installer’s voice – the national domestic gas boiler survey 2017



What have nearly 600 engineers got to say about the boilers they work on every day?



Whenever 2 engineers get together down the pub for a pint, or indeed log onto an online forum, they will invariably discuss the various merits of the boilers they work on. Some will be extremely loyal to one brand – others will fit whatever the consumer wants, or what’s on offer at their local merchant. This is often cause for a wonderfully heated debate, although there is rarely any resolution. Having heard these ‘discussions’ at the trade counter and been guilty of getting out the popcorn when ‘it’s going off on Facebook’, we decided to try and find the definitive answer to the question – “What’s the best domestic gas boiler available on the UK market?”.


Williams & Co launched this comprehensive survey in September 2016. There were some initial qualifying questions (how many boilers do you fit, how much influence do you have and so on). The survey was in 5 sections, with questions about the manufacturers support and service, including technical helplines. There are then in-depth questions about combis, regular and system boilers. In these sections, respondents were asked their opinions about ease of installation, build quality, how easy the boiler was to service and some further questions about spares. The engineers had to have worked on the boiler over the last 12 months. A final question asked what they would say to the MD of a manufacturer if they had his ear.


The real value of the survey however, is when we asked the installer which boiler manufacturer they would recommend for 3 different budgets (small, medium and money no object), and for combi, regular and system boilers. These are the findings, with nearly 600 verified Gas Safe Registered engineers giving freely of their expertise and insights from working on them.

Full results now available here
 
Courtesy of my colleague Paul Jepson, who has been working on this for months.
 
I had no idea Intergas was so popular. The new model has a diverter valve, that for me was one of the only selling points. So why's it so popular?
 
I've only fitted one, but will certainly fit another. The heat exchanger looks like it belongs in a tank, proper old fashioned substantial one with decent sized water pathways inside.

It also comes with a Honeywell programmable room thermostat and the RF receiver is actually inside the boiler so saves a couple of hours of wiring work once you've plumbed and filled up the boiler.

I really like the design and would fit them again. Will most likely do soon now that Ideal are insisting you fit their magnetic filter for a 10 year warranty on the Vogues. Don't like anti-competitive policies like that so am going to stop fitting them.
 
I always fit filters where possible, it saves on the manufacturers get out, " it needs flushing"
The hex might be massive, but not having a diverter valve brings its own issues, hard water can clog the hex with limes scale.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Reply to Williams & Co 2017 boiler survey results in the Plumbing Jobs | The Job-board area at PlumbersForums.net

Similar plumbing topics

Had our gas Baxi Combi inspected and serviced today, as it has been every year. Gas safety cert issued and says all okay, but engineer gave what I think was very... ambiguous... advice. 12yo boiler with the following readings on the analyser printout: O2% = 4.1 CO ppm = 192 CO2% = 9.5 Ratio =...
Replies
4
Views
557
Hi All, We have finally decided after a bit of a persuasion to have installed a utility room in our garage that currently houses our oil boiler. Initially we thought the boiler may stay in place but after discussions with the builder we would have to move the boiler to replace the floor and...
Replies
7
Views
840
[ASIDE: I did wonder if this was the best forum for this but figured as it was a boiler related issue that the gas engineers would be dealing with it as a matter of course. If I'm wrong can someone let me know and I'll shift it to a better place.] I have a condensing boiler installation...
Replies
5
Views
228
Hi all, I wanted to ask a general question about an underfloor heating system our plumber is proposing and if this solution will be sufficient to heat the rooms. We have only a woodburning stove (15kW nominal output) that heats our open plan lounge/kitchen/diner directly (6.5kW from the...
Replies
1
Views
452
Hello there, I have quite a story and a looking for some advice here. On Thursday during the cold snap our hot water stopped working (in the sense of not water at all coming out of the taps). The central heating was working fine. As I have two newborns and having encountered this for the very...
Replies
6
Views
1K
Creating content since 2001. Untold Media.

Newest Plumbing Threads

Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock