Search the forum,

Scaled Heat Exchanger? Bad enough to cause problem?

Discuss Scaled Heat Exchanger? Bad enough to cause problem? in the Plumbing Jobs | The Job-board area at PlumbersForums.net

M

MAXEON

Messages
13
I was recently advised "heat exchanger scaled" on a Worcester Bosch SiII combi boiler. There was a DW intermitent problem - sometimes DHW ran cold after a short while - other times worked okay. Gas installer diagnosed scaled hex. Options were to have new hex (mega cost) or replace boiler. As boiler was get ting on a bit, opted for new boiler. I retained old boiler and for curiosity, extracted the hex and cut open to see what a scaled hex looks like. See pics attached. One of the pics is of the DHW f & r pipes. I could see straight through all the pathways of the main part - including the pipes within outer pipes although difficult to show this in a photo.
Does this look like it should have caused the problem . Comments please.
CIMG6831.JPG CIMG6832.JPG CIMG6838.JPG CIMG6848.JPG CIMG6831.JPG CIMG6831.JPG CIMG6832.JPG CIMG6838.JPG CIMG6848.JPG
 
I would say that a scaled heat ex would be faulty all the time, not intermittently. Did the engineer not offer to descale it? How much did he quote to change heat ex and how much was you charged for a new boiler?
 
Yep, that hex is in a bad state. To be fair, it was on a very old boiler that could’ve been riddled with lots of other intermittent failing components. I would’ve classed that appliance as ‘beyond economical repair’
He did completely the right thing by replacing it.
 
Craig’s comments are spot on.

That does not look like a set of tubes that have been used in a hard water area - do you know the hardness of the water feeding your boiler?

Having said that structurally the exchanger looks in poor condition
 
The boiler was 13 years old (not what I would consider to be very old) in 2 bed flat in appartment block with reasonably good insulation mostly occupied by 1 person so not had a 'heavy duty' hard life. Water is classed as "slightly hard" by Severn Trent Water - no limescale accumalates on taps/shower head. Obviously, there is some limescale, but the layer that can be seen on the hex is about (I estimate) 0.05mm (1/20th) so I wouldn't have thought enough to affect the performance of the hex to any significant degree and certainly none of the pathways were blocked so flow rate would not be affected to cause over heating hence my suprise. I was quite expecting to find a blocked or virtually blocked hex and was somewhat suprised at what I saw hence my post to this form for views from you people in the industry.
 
Craig Watson said:
I would say that a scaled heat ex would be faulty all the time, not intermittently. Did the engineer not offer to descale it? How much did he quote to change heat ex and how much was you charged for a new boiler?
Click to expand...

No offer to descale. The boiler was covered by maintenance contract (no company name to mention at present as I am having a 'dialogue' with them) but of course the hex not covered! I was just given the option of new hex or new boiler. As the boiler was 13 years old and the cost to replace the hex was around £500 inc fitting, I considered more sensible to replace boiler. I have a bit of a techy background so for interest I extracted the hex from the old boiler to see what it "scaled heat exchanger" looked like in real life!
 
MAXEON said:
Having looked at the MIs for the old boiler and the flowchart for the symptoms (intermittent DHW fault) and being suprised at how unblocked the HEX looked to me, I suspect the real fault may have been a faulty thermistor or temp sensor or flow sensor?
Click to expand...
Your problems was relying on a large company - have a read of my post in "Long boiler warranties? Worth it? "

(Shamelessly plugging his own posting :rolleyes::oops:)
 

Reply to Scaled Heat Exchanger? Bad enough to cause problem? in the Plumbing Jobs | The Job-board area at PlumbersForums.net

Similar plumbing topics

C
Outer flow limited, unknown problem to solve
Hello, recently our boiler stopped working properly, causing a lack of heat in our 14-radiator splitter in 3 storeys. having only one boiler at time it kind of working, only for one at time (and partially hot), depending on the priority in the system. We contacted Valliant for assistance...
Replies
4
Views
382
cily35
C
B
Glow Worm Fuelsaver 40B Mk2 Heat Exchanger Kettling
I have an old Glow Worm Fuelsaver 40B Mk 2 installed on the kitchen wall. In November, the heat exchanger began making a kettling noise. It’s done this before. In the past, simply draining and refilling the system to flush out loose deposits was enough to stop the noise. In November 2021, I...
Replies
3
Views
2K
brian_mk
B
E
Blocked Heat Exchanger?
The central heating system (Valliant Ecomax 622, 8 large double radiators) had been losing pressure for several months and I'd been topping it up every other day during the cold periods, but it hardly needed it when the heating was off for a while. The radiators had been making 'tinkling' sounds...
Replies
12
Views
4K
Electrophase
E
P
Complete central heating system setup - advice please
Hi there, please help dont have a clue how to set this up. Ive recently installed a complete new central heating system in my house myself. The system is up and running and works okay but I feel it could work alot better if it were setup properly. Im not a plumber and really understand how parts...
Replies
22
Views
3K
Ric2013
R
O
Heat Exchanger for new Boiler
Hi all, 25 year old boiler need replacing. Existing boiler, 220 kW doing Aged Care Facility. I want to install a condensing boiler, but are worried about not being able to clean the system efficiently to not cause damage to the new boiler and void warranty. The best option I can see is to have...
Replies
14
Views
3K
Scott_D
Scott_D
Creating content since 2001. Untold Media.

Newest Plumbing Threads

Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock