Search the forum,

Discuss Xs air at 500 in the Plumbing Jobs | The Job-board area at PlumbersForums.net

Status
Not open for further replies.
R

richardd

I carried out a check on a flue today.all other measurements were fine ratio o.oo25. The xs air seemed very high thou 500 as I have stated . The boiler was a Worcester si model 10year old and the flue run vertically for 2.5meters until it exited the property on a pitched roof.
Could someone explain xs air in more detail and this reading. I know high reading can effect fuel consumption. But is there any safety issues here thanks . I am in my first year on the register.
 
Xs air?

Not familiar with this richardd ... O2, CO2 & CO .. What FGA you using?
 
Co2 percentage 16percent .mi states 14percent adjusting tomorrow.
 
Hey always learning ... I now have a handle on excess air .. :) Amazing what technolgy does! So what is a "normal" reading on the Xs scale ??? :)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
My usual reading is around 30 on a horizontal flue straight out the wall. I got 480 on this flue I assumed it was because it was vertical and had a run of 2.5 meters.

I have done a bit of research myself it seems it is the amount of extra air present to assist combustion. So therebis no safety issue I presume but would like to hear further opinions.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Okay done a bit more reading on the excess air to get my own understanding on it. It's a measurement of "air" present in the exhaust flue. The higher the percentage reading the greater the dilution of flue gasses and is calculated by measuring the presence of oxygen in the flue. the less oxygen present the lower the excess air percentage reading.

A reading of 500% tells you there was a lot of air present... Possibility for this could be that the reading was taken on low fire with a fan flued boiler?

How does that sound? It makes sense for me anyhoo's!!! :)
 
Ok. My understanding of excess air is that it's the measurement off too much air over stychiometric combustion. So the average is about 30

Too much air will severely affect the efficiency of the appliance

To me. In this situation I would say that you have a undergassed appliance of you have a fault in your flue

You will want to get that ex air right down to have good efficiency. Check you on high fire
Gas rate
You may have by now found your fault
 
In this situation I would say that you have a undergassed appliance of you have a fault in your flue

You will want to get that ex air right down to have good efficiency. Check you on high fire
Gas rate
You may have by now found your fault

Hi SimonJohn ... The boiler in question is fan flued not pre-mix which may explain the Xs air readings. I don't think it neccesseraly means there's a fault :) These fans aren't variable speed, they're either fixed or 2 speed whereas the boilers are modulating so as the burner pressure drops you're gonna get an increase in Xs air if the fan is constant yeh?
 
But 500% excess air is far too much

Even on low fire of a non premix that is crazy. I would be looking at 125% ish for low and 20-30 on high. Doesnt seen right to me
 
But 500% excess air is far too much

Even on low fire of a non premix that is crazy. I would be looking at 125% ish for low and 20-30 on high. Doesnt seen right to me

Just reading back through and you say you have a co2 of 16%. That's very high. But won't explain the excess air. If anything you should have very little excess air. What was your O2?
 
But 500% excess air is far too much

Even on low fire of a non premix that is crazy. I would be looking at 125% ish for low and 20-30 on high. Doesnt seen right to me

My FGA is a dinosaur mate and doesn't do this Xs air thing! I'm learning something new here to be honest as it's not a term I've come across in this sheltered self employed life I lead :) Is it possible for a poorly positioned analyser probe to give these sorts of readings? I'll be paying more attention in future to the O2 readings I'm taking though as i now have the calculation you do to determine Xs :) Always learning eh :)
 
What analyser do you have?

The analyser should be positioned where manufacturer says

On certain Hamworthy boilers. If the FGA prove is not in the right area of the combustion chamber it will give incorrect readings

On a OF boiler. If you sample after draught divertor then you will only ever achieve readings of co2 at about 3.5% and you will have a stupid excess air

But on domestic all you should be worrying about is what the mi's say.

500% could even mean that his O2 cell is broken.

Most of the time you would be looking 9-11% co2
4-7%o2
25 -120 excess air. Boiler dependant
0-200 ppm
Ft non cond 120 cond 90 (30c above flow temp)


Obviously these are average figures. Always refer to mi!!
 
Got a TESTO 325 bought 2nd hand 3 years ago!

Thanks for the info ... I'd guessed that you'd have stupid numbers with open flue in secondary flueway :)
 
Got a TESTO 325 bought 2nd hand 3 years ago!

Thanks for the info ... I'd guessed that you'd have stupid numbers with open flue in secondary flueway :)

The 325 can do excess air. It's the funny looking y shape. I'll double check thou. My apprentice has one
 
Just checked and it does do excess air. It's the EA option

If your not sure how to set it up I'll send you the link to the manual
 
Please SimonJohn ... I've got the thing in front of me and it doesn't seem to have anything regards xs... it's the testo 325-M ... whether the 'M' makes any diff I don't know :)
 
Hey, Richard. I know you said this was an older Si, but do you have a GC number for it? You've got me all kinds of curious about 14% CO2 per MIs. Natural gas has a CO2 max of 11.9% so I'm dead curious how the manus expect you to get 14%!
 
Hey, Richard. I know you said this was an older Si, but do you have a GC number for it? You've got me all kinds of curious about 14% CO2 per MIs. Natural gas has a CO2 max of 11.9% so I'm dead curious how the manus expect you to get 14%!

Good shout CMariD ... I have the mi's for GCno 47-311-65 and it states 5.3 - 6.2 CO2 ---- Someone's FGA needs calibrating maybe :)
 
:angry_smile: I've got the lip on CMariD Mines only an M :wheelchair: and not XL :tank:
 
Diamond, I have 47-311-49 & 51 for the 25/28si (not Greenstar!) and they're asking for 5.5%-8.5% CO2.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You know what me ole' mam used to say? "If you keep pouting like that, you'll trip over your lip!"

:wink:
 
You know what me ole' mam used to say? "If you keep pouting like that, you'll trip over your lip!"

:wink:

Mothers are always right too Mari :)

Back to the post ..... whatever si the op has though, there seems to be something wrong with the readings they've posted, as SimonJohns points out, would you agree?
 
Mothers are always right too Mari :)

Back to the post ..... whatever si the op has though, there seems to be something wrong with the readings they've posted, as SimonJohns points out, would you agree?

I agree with Simon ... something's amiss and like him I'd be curious to see the O2% and well as a double check of the CO2 reading. Well, while your at it, just scan us the print out! :)

I can never remember seeing excess air has high as 50%, much less 500%. Got a stack of print outs on my desk at work so I'll have a jolly good rummage tomorrow.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Reply to Xs air at 500 in the Plumbing Jobs | The Job-board area at PlumbersForums.net

Creating content since 2001. Untold Media.

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock