Posting a message to the forum will remove the above advertisement
  1. Hi, welcome to the new look - Login with your usual login details, or sign up if you don't already have an account. If you post just once, all the advertisements get automatically removed. We have some competitions coming soon, and lots of new feaures. 

Discuss Would you REALLY always recommend running UFH constantly? in the Central Heating Forum area at

  1. Ric2013

    Ric2013 Plumber

    Been adding UnderFloor Heating to my own house and it's running provisionally. Controls yet to be wired. Can't think of ideal system but this is the best I can think of myself:

    Since the UFH is auxiliary to a radiator (theoretically not enough output from UFH to hold its own in cold weather), I decided to try plumbing the manifold (with pump, mixing valve assembly etc) with flow and returns from the heating circuit and room temperature control using the same stat that runs the central heating. Timber floors and spreader plates, so response time isn't too bad.

    Existing room stat is in the room heated by UFH - house is open plan and most of the heat goes upstairs anyway, but bedrooms do not overheat as they are controlled by TRVs and doors kept shut.

    Basically, the UFH will come on when everything else is on. The radiator will provide the main heat, and then the UFH will help keep the room and floor warm. In warmer weather, the radiator can be shut off using the manual control valve.

    I know it's usually advised to have the UFH on its own zone, but my thought is that all that will happen is that my old cast-iron-heat-exhanger-non-condensing boiler will cycle continually and reduce the system efficiency significantly (that would be an 8.5kW boiler running at 1.2kW demand... ) and heat losses from pipework would effectively heat the whole house to some degree anyway (centre terrace - so not a huge heat requirement) . The radiators in other rooms currently in use are just two - my bedroom (in practice, the TRV normally closes fully) and the bathroom (600Wish, but usually half-warm due to TRV).

    Also, days like today the windows can be open most of the day and it seems wrong to have heating on with open windows. Last three days heating has been on for an hour or two each evening and then I switch it off and sit by the fire instead.

    Does my reasoning about the UFH make sense to anyone else, given that I'll be the one using it? I know I'm weird, but I wanted a reality check when it came to system design.
  2. SimonG

    SimonG Trusted Plumber

    Just to confirm. Rads and floor come on together but you have thermostatic control on the floor water temperature?
  3. Chalked

    Chalked Plumber GSR

    Will sort of work but your floor will slowly reach 60-70 degrees.!
  4. Ric2013

    Ric2013 Plumber

    Some confusion. To clarify:

    Simon G: Correct - there is a thermostatic mixing valve on the UFH manifold and a floor sensor that will shut down the UFH if floor gets too hot.

    Chalked: There will be a thermostat set on the floor to limit the maximum floor temperature by closing the zone valve to the UFH manifold and shutting down the UFH pump. This will not switch off the rest of the heating system.
Similar Threads - REALLY always recommend Forum Date
I'm really board!!!! General Off-Topic Chat Jun 12, 2017
Really not a good day!!! Plumbers Arms May 11, 2017
Really? Whats the point? Gas Safe Register Forum - Public Forum Apr 16, 2017
Controlling underfloor heating - what rocks your world? ( & works really well with condensing boiler Underfloor Heating Forum Apr 2, 2017
When is a room air vent for flame effect gas fire really needed (with BS) Plumbing Forum Jan 23, 2017
Why can't we get a really hot shower? Or cold? Plumbed the wrong way around? Plumbing Forum Jan 11, 2017
Is a drain really necessary with a deck mounted showed head? Plumbing Forum Dec 5, 2016